Quote:
Originally Posted by drewl
10 THINGS WE LEARNED LAST NIGHT
1. Your next American Idol is ......David Cook... well at this point it is his to lose!
2. Sayesha has a future as a broadway singer! (that was a terrific performance last night!!)
3. Carly - let someone else pick the song for you please! (Great job on a big song!)
4. David A - the boy can sing, too bad he didn't sing last night.. oh wait he did, I have no recollection of his performance, did he sing Imagine by John lennon.. no? oops, that was a few weeks ago.. So much talent, so much cuteness, so little stage charisma and variation.. he could still wake up and come back and win this, he'll also need to wake the rest of us up as other than his die hard fans I think America is starting to take an extra bathroom break during his performances.
5. Jason - Has neverr seen a Lord Weber musical before, Dude... Ah.. it showed DOH!!
6. Brooke - This will probably be her last performance on the show this year. You just can't stop and start twice in a season.. once ok, but not twice, and the poor thing is so emotional. I dread the scene if she is eliminated! Please be nice tonight Ryan
7. This was the week where we forced people into uncomfortable situations.. David C showed us why he will probably win, Jason why he probably won't
8. "Lord" Andrew llloyd Weber is an awkward little man...
9. Paula actually CAN say something less than positive 
10. Even when she does, Simon will disagree with her to annoy her. 
Clearly there were 3 really good performances, one ok, and two train wrecks.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by jaybird
I'm sorry folks. I know there are some David Archuleta fans here. The kid is a good singer alright. If he were my kid I would be way the heck proud of him. He just bores the crap out of me......like plain white milquetoast. He's the only one left that I dread seeing each week. Too much "Who me?" "Oh shucks" "Golly gee". Great kid...but a super star? Oh well.
|
You took the works right out of my mouth, Jaybird. He's got a nice voice. But his lack of charisma and whole demeanor just make me cringe.
Absolutely NO star quality.
I heart David Cook. I get goosebumps when he sings.
And I am a Carly fan.