[drewl]

Originally Posted by Eileencc

Alright, so check it out...almost all the song choices tonight sucked! How could the producers choose Dan Fogelberg for David A, and how could Simon choose Robert Flack for David C. I did love Syesha's Alicia Keys song. And I got goosebumps on David C's Aerosmith. Let's face it though, trying to cram a 3:00 song into 1:30 just isn't fair to the song or the artists. All the songs just felt truncated and wrong to me. Why not let them have a full 3:00 and only do 2 songs? Or extend the show to 90 minutes if necessary. Tonight was just alright for me, dawg. It's tough to predict, but I think it's gonna be the two Davids.

PS...I hope I never hear David A. utter the word "boo" again, unless it's Halloween.

I couldn't agree more.. why 3 songs? I'd rather see 2 songs performed more fully.
Well, I think the odds say David/David... but frankly, while David A nevers gets "pitchy" he is flat out boring. Couldn't have been any clearer than hsi fogelberg efffort.. he clearly was singing the right words and notes, but no clue as to the what the song meant and no passion... Yaen City. It should be David C vs Syesha.. but... the fans decided. ANYTHING CAN HAPPEN!