love...love...love La Tortuga. i've stayed there about 10 times. the setting is absolutely gorgeous. the pool and grounds are well kept. you get a complimentary breakfast with your stay and it's more then just a continental breakfast...plus you get discounts on other meals there too. the staff makes you feel very welcome. great location. i could go on and on.
congrats on your anniversary. when in May are you going to be in Playa?