American Idol, here we go again

[jaybird]

Originally Posted by Mamacita

Wow. Jason blew chunks. I hope he goes bye-bye.

My husband has commented that he thinks David A looks like a chimp and calls him Cornelius. So now he's ruined for me. I have to look away. Couldn't even pull a rockin' song out of his a$$ on ROCK AND ROLL NIGHT!!!

Thought David C's second song was better than his first, and he did pretty good, but not really his best night.

And Syesha is really getting good. I hope for David C and Syesha in the top two, but prolly David A will go there instead of her. Oh well.

I'm actually voting this week for the first time this season. David Cook and Syesha for me.

Funny you said that about David A. For me it's like having a tooth pulled watching that kid. Thank God for DVR. I fast forward through his songs after I listen for a few seconds. I almost feel bad since he's such a sweet kid. Just torture to watch.

And Jason? ............Sorry

[SunKneeMarie]

I still think it will be the two Davids as the final 2... but I sure hope it's Syesha as #3... what was that with Jason? bleh

[hal]

I know Jason sucked big time this week but I'd still rather see David A. leave. I'm getting really sick of the judges (and audience) hype of that kid .

[Jacko]

Originally Posted by SunKneeMarie

I still think it will be the two Davids as the final 2... but I sure hope it's Syesha as #3... what was that with Jason? bleh

I agree! I have had the same concerns as Hal in the past, but I think David Arrachera () sounded much better tonight..

[Mamacita]

Originally Posted by Jacko

I agree! I have had the same concerns as Hal in the past, but I think David Arrachera () sounded much better tonight..

That got a LOL out of me!

Yeah, the kid can sing, but if you can't stand to look at him...what then?

[UGAplaya]

One word for me......Syesha!!! WOW, her first song was great and she looked like a million dollars. And for the record, I'm really over David Cook. All of his stuff is really starting to sound the same. Kind of the same with David A. too for me. Gotta love Jason Castro. Poor guy last night... LOL

[drewl]

Originally Posted by Mamacita

Wow. Jason blew chunks. I hope he goes bye-bye.

My husband has commented that he thinks David A looks like a chimp and calls him Cornelius. So now he's ruined for me. I have to look away. Couldn't even pull a rockin' song out of his a$$ on ROCK AND ROLL NIGHT!!!

Thought David C's second song was better than his first, and he did pretty good, but not really his best night.

And Syesha is really getting good. I hope for David C and Syesha in the top two, but prolly David A will go there instead of her. Oh well.

That's too funny and pefect!! Cornelius!!
Jason chuncked it big time, that was embarrassing.. and forgetting words, and butchering Bob Marley... ug.. I guess we will find out this week how much pull "vote for the worst" actually has.

[drewl]

Originally Posted by hal

I know Jason sucked big time this week but I'd still rather see David A. leave. I'm getting really sick of the judges (and audience) hype of that kid .

And he is so boring... same thing over and over again... I completely forgot what song he sang the first time until they did the recap... I just go into tune out mode when he sings. Sure he hits the notes, sue he isn't pitchy.. but yawn-O-rama!
Jason should go home.. but don't be surprised if it is Syesha.. not that she deserves it.

[drewl]

Originally Posted by jaybird

I'm actually voting this week for the first time this season. David Cook and Syesha for me.

Funny you said that about David A. For me it's like having a tooth pulled watching that kid. Thank God for DVR. I fast forward through his songs after I listen for a few seconds. I almost feel bad since he's such a sweet kid. Just torture to watch.

And Jason? ............Sorry

Jason was some serious stinky poopoo!

[E in DC]

Jason just plain sucked.

I agree with the comments about David A. There is no there there.

Syesha was impressive.

David Cook is the only Idol contestant in history whose album I might actually buy.

And about the debate over the talent of this year's finalists. . . I really only started watching two years ago and I have to say that David Cook and Syesha are a hell of a lot better than Taylor Hicks and Catherine McPhee.

[btodd]

You got that right!!

[drewl]

Originally Posted by E in DC

Jason just plain sucked.

I agree with the comments about David A. There is no there there.

Syesha was impressive.

David Cook is the only Idol contestant in history whose album I might actually buy.

And about the debate over the talent of this year's finalists. . . I really only started watching two years ago and I have to say that David Cook and Syesha are a hell of a lot better than Taylor Hicks and Catherine McPhee.

Well taylor for sure was a commercial bust... and clearly Syesha has a future on broadway... I think David A has a clear future singing and croonie to nursing homes.

[James A.]

Syesha will win the whole shooting match.

[Jacko]

IMO, it will be the weakest final three in American Idol history.

[UGAplaya]

Originally Posted by James A.

Syesha will win the whole shooting match.

She was on her game last night. And that dress.........wow!!