American Idol, here we go again - Page 51

Jan&Chas · 05-15-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by drewl

I forgot about the fantasia performance.. what was that? Simon looked like he wasn't sure if it were a joke or not.. nice hair though eh?

I did not like her performance and I felt the same way Simon looked.

JameyBano · 05-20-2008

SOOO excited for tonight (I need to get a life!)
Go David C!!
I predict that David A will sing a ballad!
BTW, we bought tickets for the American Idol concert here in Fort Fun on Sept 10th!

E in DC · 05-20-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by JameyBano

SOOO excited for tonight (I need to get a life!)
Go David C!!
I predict that David A will sing a ballad!
BTW, we bought tickets for the American Idol concert here in Fort Fun on Sept 10th!

Way to go out there on a limb with that prediction, JameyB!

I'm excited too.

btodd · 05-20-2008

I am so excited too, but I have a board meeting tonight at 7:00!! I will tape the program ( now I am dating myself) and watch when I get home..................
DAVID COOK ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!

Jacko · 05-20-2008

I can hardly believe I am saying this, but I do believe that Archuleta outdid David Cook with the first song.......I think it is the best performance he has ever done....and Elton John is not easy to do!

Finally, some excitement from David A.! Fantastic!

Babaloo · 05-20-2008

the kid bores me to tears
sounds like he's singing a bad Bette Midler song

Jacko · 05-20-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Babaloo

the kid bores me to tears
sounds like he's singing a bad Bette Midler song

I mostly agree... but I really liked his first song....the second one...not so much...but David Cook is not nearly as good as he usually is IMO....
its something to do as I sit in a hotel room in Charlotte waiting on Linda to arrive home from Madrid....Linda is sitting in the airport in Miami...and they just cancelled her flight...so we both will have separate hotel rooms in separate cities...now THAT's boring!

Babaloo · 05-20-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jacko

...so we both will have separate hotel rooms in separate cities...now THAT's boring!

go see my folks!
hurry...they go to bed in 15 minutes!!

Eileencc · 05-20-2008

Ruh-roh! Big DC fan sees trouble ahead.

I think DA took the night. I loved DC's U2 song, his other two not so much. I have to admit that I liked all three of David A's performances. As Simon said, it seemed like David A came to win, and David C was ever so slightly off his game. I really would have like to see David C rock out as I know he can. He was slightly subdued, and IMO, he was just OK tonight. I had better go start voting now because he's gonna need all the votes he can get! I can't wait till he gets his album made and can go out touring because I'll be right there in line buying tickets!

GO DAVID COOK!!!

JameyBano · 05-20-2008

liked David C's first and last songs, and as I predicted David A sung only ballads with his eyes all squinty. Judges were a little over the top with all their praise, especially since Simon was on all the talk shows predicting a Cook win. Liked Michael Buffer--- that never gets old!
have texted and got through a few times for David C on the 5703# on my home phone, never able to get through on the 5701 and 5705 # on my cells.
Do not know what to watch with no more Survivor, Dancing with the Stars, and American Idol?

Jacko · 05-20-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by JameyBano

liked David C's first and last songs, and as I predicted David A sung only ballads with his eyes all squinty. Judges were a little over the top with all their praise, especially since Simon was on all the talk shows predicting a Cook win. Liked Michael Buffer--- that never gets old!
have texted and got through a few times for David C on the 5703# on my home phone, never able to get through on the 5701 and 5705 # on my cells.
Do not know what to watch with no more Survivor, Dancing with the Stars, and American Idol?

So You Think You Can Dance....the best of all of them IMO...

Trish · 05-20-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jacko

So You Think You Can Dance....the best of all of them IMO...

This is next on my DVR, too!

Mercy · 05-20-2008

I know I've been in the minority here but I have been a David A fan since the get-go, and he certainly didn't let me down tonight.

Don't get me wrong, I like David C also, but frankly his rock thing is getting old. All his rock songs sound alike to me.

Vocally, between the two, there is no competition. David A is clearly the better singer, his voice is simply amazing.

licuadora · 05-20-2008

Well I wouldn't walk across the street to see the little squinty guy perform another ballad even if the show was free. But on the other hand I would pay to go hear David Cook sing in concert. Isn't that what the contest is about?
Boring, boring ballads... blah. Rock on David Cook!

Eileencc · 05-20-2008

I love David Cook's "rock thing." He rarely let that side out because people slammed him for showing attitude. Frankly, I'd like to see it more. And I really like his voice. That's not to say I don't like David A's voice. He's got a terrific voice but he's very boring to watch...he mostly stands awkwardly on the stage. He'll get better with age and experience. I think David C will be amazing to watch in person. I do hope he wins, but in any case, both of these performers are going to be stars.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

05-20-2008	#752 (permalink)
JameyBano life=playa Join Date: May 2007 Location: Fort Wayne, IN Posts: 777	SOOO excited for tonight (I need to get a life!) Go David C!! I predict that David A will sing a ballad! BTW, we bought tickets for the American Idol concert here in Fort Fun on Sept 10th!

05-20-2008	#754 (permalink)
btodd reposado Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada Posts: 1,276	I am so excited too, but I have a board meeting tonight at 7:00!! I will tape the program ( now I am dating myself) and watch when I get home.................. DAVID COOK ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!

05-20-2008	#755 (permalink)
Jacko añejo Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 17,257	I can hardly believe I am saying this, but I do believe that Archuleta outdid David Cook with the first song.......I think it is the best performance he has ever done....and Elton John is not easy to do! Finally, some excitement from David A.! Fantastic!

05-20-2008	#756 (permalink)
Babaloo añejo Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Paamul, Q Roo Mexico Posts: 10,171	the kid bores me to tears sounds like he's singing a bad Bette Midler song

05-20-2008	#759 (permalink)
Eileencc añejo Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: North of Boston, Mass Posts: 3,857	Ruh-roh! Big DC fan sees trouble ahead. I think DA took the night. I loved DC's U2 song, his other two not so much. I have to admit that I liked all three of David A's performances. As Simon said, it seemed like David A came to win, and David C was ever so slightly off his game. I really would have like to see David C rock out as I know he can. He was slightly subdued, and IMO, he was just OK tonight. I had better go start voting now because he's gonna need all the votes he can get! I can't wait till he gets his album made and can go out touring because I'll be right there in line buying tickets! GO DAVID COOK!!!

05-20-2008	#760 (permalink)
JameyBano life=playa Join Date: May 2007 Location: Fort Wayne, IN Posts: 777	liked David C's first and last songs, and as I predicted David A sung only ballads with his eyes all squinty. Judges were a little over the top with all their praise, especially since Simon was on all the talk shows predicting a Cook win. Liked Michael Buffer--- that never gets old! have texted and got through a few times for David C on the 5703# on my home phone, never able to get through on the 5701 and 5705 # on my cells. Do not know what to watch with no more Survivor, Dancing with the Stars, and American Idol?

05-20-2008	#763 (permalink)
Mercy añejo Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Physically Maryland/Mentally the Beach Posts: 1,503	I know I've been in the minority here but I have been a David A fan since the get-go, and he certainly didn't let me down tonight. Don't get me wrong, I like David C also, but frankly his rock thing is getting old. All his rock songs sound alike to me. Vocally, between the two, there is no competition. David A is clearly the better singer, his voice is simply amazing.

05-20-2008	#764 (permalink)
licuadora life=playa Join Date: Jul 2005 Location: Austin Posts: 518	Well I wouldn't walk across the street to see the little squinty guy perform another ballad even if the show was free. But on the other hand I would pay to go hear David Cook sing in concert. Isn't that what the contest is about? Boring, boring ballads... blah. Rock on David Cook!

05-20-2008	#765 (permalink)
Eileencc añejo Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: North of Boston, Mass Posts: 3,857	I love David Cook's "rock thing." He rarely let that side out because people slammed him for showing attitude. Frankly, I'd like to see it more. And I really like his voice. That's not to say I don't like David A's voice. He's got a terrific voice but he's very boring to watch...he mostly stands awkwardly on the stage. He'll get better with age and experience. I think David C will be amazing to watch in person. I do hope he wins, but in any case, both of these performers are going to be stars.

register to remove these adverts