American Idol, here we go again - Page 9

Sukidog · 02-28-2008

After that young man David A. sang the other nite, I think it's pretty clear who the Next American Idol is going to be. Everyone else may as well go home. Seacrest OUT!

drewl · 02-28-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sukidog

After that young man David A. sang the other nite, I think it's pretty clear who the Next American Idol is going to be. Everyone else may as well go home. Seacrest OUT!

Sounds like the Melinda Doolittle thing last year.. um, but surprisngly she didn't win. The wild card is the Voters and it seems as the field gets smaller, sometimes people to try to keep someone they like forget to vote the person they like best. We'll see, it's pretty amazing how much people can develop. In my opinion, there are 4 or 5 right now who could win it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mamacita

Comments on the girls and guys this week?

I liked Michael Johns this week (the Aussie).

I wish I could remember more of their real names...but maybe that's the problem...they're unremarkable, unmemorable.

The girls kinda sucked. But I liked the Carly Simon girl.

I think the idea of having a bunch of ringers is backfiring a little...? Or do this many always suck at this point? I think so. That Danny Noriega kid has got to go!!!

Other than maybe 2 of them, the girls were pretty bad with bad song choices and bad arrangements. The boys seem much stronger and yes, Danny HAS to go! The sooner the better.!!

maas1114 · 02-28-2008

The only girl that I actually liked last night was Carly..the Irish Tattoo girl.

jaybird · 02-28-2008

I thought Chikezie finally did good. Enjoyed him this week.
The nellie guy's gotta go.

I liked a couple of the girls. Amanda the rocker will get in trouble when she actually has to sing. I like her but don't think she has much of a singing voice.

Buns · 02-28-2008

OK guys...here's my OFFICIAL picks for whose going home this week...

For GIRLS...I think Kady Malloy and Amanda Overmyer are going home.

For BOYS...I will pick...Jason Yaeger and Robbie Carrico.

I have not liked Jason since the very first time I've seen him, and I just read that Robbie DOES wear a wig!! I think Kady is a fake, and I HATE the way Amanda sings.

travmagic · 02-28-2008

From the guys this week I liked the 3 Davids.
From the girls I liked Brooke, Asia( I actually thought she got in because they felt sorry for her because her Dad died but I think she did a good job tonight) and Carly.

Mercy · 02-28-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sukidog

After that young man David A. sang the other nite, I think it's pretty clear who the Next American Idol is going to be. Everyone else may as well go home. Seacrest OUT!

I totally agree. However with the American public voting, who knows what will happen

Of the girls I like Carly the Irish girl the best, and I like Brooke also. Can't stand Amanda... gosh she did horrible last night.

Buns · 02-29-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buns

OK guys...here's my OFFICIAL picks for whose going home this week...

For GIRLS...I think Kady Malloy and Amanda Overmyer are going home.

For BOYS...I will pick...Jason Yaeger and Robbie Carrico.

Well...I got the boys right! I was TOTALLY surprised that Alexandrea got sent home!! I thought she was great!

jaybird · 02-29-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buns

Well...I got the boys right! I was TOTALLY surprised that Alexandrea got sent home!! I thought she was great!

Good picking.

I sure wasn't disappointed to see any of them go, although I didn't expect Alexandrea to go either.

Maybe we can lose the nellie "ish" guy next week.

drewl · 02-29-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buns

Well...I got the boys right! I was TOTALLY surprised that Alexandrea got sent home!! I thought she was great!

Very nice picking... While maybe a little surprising, I don't think we lost anyone who was going to win it. I didn't watch the results show as it conflicts with Survivor! Any idea what type of songs they have to sing next week?

JameyBano · 02-29-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by drewl

Very nice picking... While maybe a little surprising, I don't think we lost anyone who was going to win it. I didn't watch the results show as it conflicts with Survivor! Any idea what type of songs they have to sing next week?

I DVR'd American Idol and watched Survivor. It then took me only 5 minutes to fast forward to see which 4 were eliminated this week!
Hopefully they are done with 60s and 70s music...maybe 80s next week??? Now THAT was real music!!!

JameyBano · 02-29-2008

Also, have they reformulated Paula's meds? She seemed normal the first few episodes, but now is slurring her words and seeing colors....

Eileencc · 02-29-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by JameyBano

Also, have they reformulated Paula's meds? She seemed normal the first few episodes, but now is slurring her words and seeing colors....

Poor Paula...I read another interview with her where she completely denied taking any drugs or alcohol whatsoever. OK, so why is she out on another planet during most shows? She DID seem normal for the first few episodes but that's all behind her now.

monte · 02-29-2008

hey fellow Zoni (Az.) what is that you HATE about the way Amanda sings? just curious, not that I like her, I just think one should give the reason on such opinion. I like your boldness

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buns

OK guys...here's my OFFICIAL picks for whose going home this week...

For GIRLS...I think Kady Malloy and Amanda Overmyer are going home.

For BOYS...I will pick...Jason Yaeger and Robbie Carrico.

I have not liked Jason since the very first time I've seen him, and I just read that Robbie DOES wear a wig!! I think Kady is a fake, and I HATE the way Amanda sings.

monte · 02-29-2008

You are so right Mercy, but no matter what the outcome of this show will be, I think this guy will be a success

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mercy

I totally agree. However with the American public voting, who knows what will happen

Of the girls I like Carly the Irish girl the best, and I like Brooke also. Can't stand Amanda... gosh she did horrible last night.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

02-28-2008	#121 (permalink)
Sukidog reposado Join Date: Sep 2004 Location: ON, Canada Posts: 1,384	After that young man David A. sang the other nite, I think it's pretty clear who the Next American Idol is going to be. Everyone else may as well go home. Seacrest OUT!

02-28-2008	#123 (permalink)
maas1114 life=playa Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Maryland USA Posts: 548	The only girl that I actually liked last night was Carly..the Irish Tattoo girl.

02-28-2008	#124 (permalink)
jaybird beachaholic Join Date: Jan 2008 Location: Farmington, NM Posts: 421	I thought Chikezie finally did good. Enjoyed him this week. The nellie guy's gotta go. I liked a couple of the girls. Amanda the rocker will get in trouble when she actually has to sing. I like her but don't think she has much of a singing voice.

02-28-2008	#125 (permalink)
Buns beachaholic Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: Phoenix, AZ Posts: 479	OK guys...here's my OFFICIAL picks for whose going home this week... For GIRLS...I think Kady Malloy and Amanda Overmyer are going home. For BOYS...I will pick...Jason Yaeger and Robbie Carrico. I have not liked Jason since the very first time I've seen him, and I just read that Robbie DOES wear a wig!! I think Kady is a fake, and I HATE the way Amanda sings.

02-28-2008	#126 (permalink)
travmagic añejo Join Date: Jul 2005 Location: New Jersey Posts: 1,666	From the guys this week I liked the 3 Davids. From the girls I liked Brooke, Asia( I actually thought she got in because they felt sorry for her because her Dad died but I think she did a good job tonight) and Carly.

02-29-2008	#132 (permalink)
JameyBano life=playa Join Date: May 2007 Location: Fort Wayne, IN Posts: 815	Also, have they reformulated Paula's meds? She seemed normal the first few episodes, but now is slurring her words and seeing colors....

register to remove these adverts