Well on this visit it's not a fair comparison since we had the Executive Suite @ ASP.....but going from memory...I would say they are very comparable.
ASP has a 2 person jacuzzi - SC was a single bath tub jacuzzi.
SC has a long narrow room - ASP was more wide but shorter.
ASP had alcohol dispensers in the room - SC does not.
ASP uses a safe with a key - SC uses an electronic safe
SC has a 4 post bed - ASP does not - Both beds are equally hard.
ASP has a larger shower then SC
SC has a larger channel choice for TV - Including Playboy on Saturday evening.
ASP has hammock's on the balcony - larger balcony then SC
Both decor's are nice
But ASP is for us.....